Buyer Guides

Healthcare Navigation Vendor Evaluation Criteria

Give every navigation vendor the same member case. Use the RFP scorecard to compare who resolves it, how they prove it, and what you pay.

The short answer

Evaluate a healthcare navigation vendor by watching it handle the same member problem you give every bidder. A confusing medical bill is a useful test. You can see who takes the case, how the vendor works with the health plan, and what the member hears when the work is done.

Use the healthcare navigation RFP scorecard to turn that demo into a decision your benefits team can defend.

Explained at three levels

1 Plain English

Think of a member who gets a bill they did not expect. Can the vendor explain what happened and stay with the case when the plan or provider has to step in? Watch the whole case before comparing the bids.

2 Informed buyer

Run your current service through the same case. That gives you a baseline for what your carrier or benefits administrator already handles and shows which work a new vendor would take on.

3 Technical and professional detail

Compare proposals against the same eligible population, service scope, and contract period. Ask bidders to identify the records they need from the plan and the events that mark a case as received, transferred, or resolved.

Healthcare navigation RFP scorecard

Copy this table into your request for proposal or demo worksheet. The example weights fit an employer that wants fewer member issues bouncing between the benefits team, the health plan, and its vendors. Agree on your own weights before bids arrive.

What each bidder should showExample weight
Member support and case ownership
Show who takes a billing question, when the member gets an update, and what ends the case.
25%
Health plan and vendor handoffs
Show who accepts a transfer, how the receiving team confirms it, and who follows up if the transfer stalls.
25%
Case reporting
Provide a sample report that separates contacts, referrals, and completed cases. Define how you count each one.
20%
Implementation and ongoing support
Provide a launch plan that names each team's work and shows how eligibility updates are tested.
15%
Full contract cost
Quote the same population and term as the other bidders. Itemize setup, recurring fees, and services that cost extra.
15%

How to score each bid

  1. List your must-haves separately. Check that each bid meets any essential terms, such as support in a particular language or a data security requirement, before comparing scores.
  2. Score each criterion from 0 to 3. Use the same scale for every bid.
    • 0. The service is unavailable.
    • 1. The bidder describes the service.
    • 2. The bidder shows how it works, with gaps.
    • 3. The service meets the agreed requirement.
  3. Keep a record of each score. Save the demo note or proposal page so another reviewer can see how you got there. Mark unanswered questions as pending and resolve them before comparing totals.
  4. Turn each score into weighted points. Divide the score by 3, then multiply by the criterion's weight. A score of 2 on a 15-point criterion earns 10 points.
  5. Add the points and compare bids. Each bid gets a total out of 100.

Watch how the vendor handles a billing question

Give each bidder the same fictional case. A member gets a bill they expected their plan to cover. They have the bill and an explanation of benefits. They want to know who is looking into it and when they will hear back.

Have the vendor walk through the case from first contact to closure. The buyer should see who takes ownership, what the member is told while the case is open, and what the vendor records when it closes the case. Ask to see the same steps through a channel your members use, such as a call or the member portal.

See who owns the case after a handoff

The useful part of the demo starts when the vendor needs the health plan or billing office to act. Have the vendor show how it sends the case, knows someone received it, and follows up when the other team needs more time.

That is where the responsibilities become clear. Put the owner for each step in the proposal so your team can see which cases will still come back to benefits staff.

Compare resolved cases and repeat contacts

Ask for a sample monthly report and have the bidder trace the demo case through it. A member might call twice and be transferred once. Find out how those events are counted and what qualifies the issue as resolved. Ask how a reopened case appears the following month.

If a bidder reports savings, ask for the calculation behind the figure, the group it covers, and how it accounts for work the health plan already does. That gives finance a basis for comparing bids.

Find out what your team has to do before launch

Ask for a launch plan that names who sends the eligibility file, who tests it, and who corrects a rejected record. Walk through a new hire appearing in the plan, then a member whose eligibility changes. Put the owner and due date beside each task.

Ask for a reference with a similar plan setup. Find out what the employer still had to handle after launch and how the vendor responded when something broke. The healthcare technology vendor selection guide covers the broader review of staffing, security, and implementation.

Put the quotes on the same footing

Give every bidder the same population and contract term. Ask who counts as a billable member, whether dependents count separately, and which charges apply if the population changes.

Have each bidder itemize setup, recurring fees, and services billed separately. Ask for the first-year total and the renewal terms in writing. Keep any performance guarantee beside the fee it affects, with the measurement and remedy spelled out.

How employers have bought healthcare navigation

Health Action Council's employer purchasing report asks how vendors handle benefits questions and measure engagement. Pinellas County's public award record shows how a buyer can specify a fee ceiling and set separate renewal options. The weights on this page are a worked example for your own review.

Where this goes next

More in Buyer Guides